School Counseling Program Comprehensive Exam Rubric for Vignette Responses

PLEASE SEE PAGE 3 for THE NEW RUBRIC. THERE IS ALSO AN ALTERNATIVE RUBRIC ON PAGE 5

School Counseling Program Comprehensive Exam
Rubric for Vignette Responses
Spring 2020
K-12 Comprehensive Examination Grading Sheet- Newest Revision

K-12 Comprehensive Examination Grading Sheet- Newest Revision
Question No. Contents 10 pts max. @ Total Scores
1. Describe the 4 themes of the ASCA National Model and how they all apply to this scenario. 10=insightful and thorough; 8-9=complete and specific; 6-7=addressed the question but vague in answers; 1-5=missed significant issues.  
2. Based on the data, what SMART goals would you establish? 10=insightful and thorough; 8-9=complete and specific; 6-7=addressed the question but vague in answers; 1-5=missed significant issues.  
3. List and describe systemic interventions you would implement as it relates to your SMART goals listed in #2. 10=insightful and thorough; 8-9=complete and specific; 6-7=addressed the question but vague in answers; 1-5=missed significant issues.  
4. Set timelines and responsibilities among you and your team to carry out your interventions in #3. 10=insightful and thorough; 8-9=complete and specific; 6-7=addressed the question but vague in answers; 1-5=missed significant issues.  
5. Who could you collaborate/consult with? Who would be the consultee? Who would be the client? 10=insightful and thorough; 8-9=complete and specific; 6-7=addressed the question but vague in answers; 1-5=missed significant issues.  
6. What data would you collect to measure the success of your interventions listed in #3? 10=covered four strategies thoroughly; 8-9=covered three to four strategies in specific ways; 6-7=covered two strategies in specific ways; 1-5= covered less than two strategies  
7. Identify any three multicultural or legal/ethical issues in this vignette and explain why these three issues need to be considered. 10=insightful and thorough; 8-9=complete and specific for both issues; 6-7=1st issue done well; 2nd vague; 1-5=missed significant issues.  
8. After collecting and analyzing data per #5 instructions, what would your final steps entail in the Disengagement stage per the Consultation Model? 10=insightful and thorough; 8-9=complete and specific for both issues; 6-7=1st issue done well; 2nd vague; 1-5=missed significant issues.  

Citation: A maximum of 5 points will be given to students. Each citation will receive one point.

TOTAL SCORES: ___________(Max. 85 points, 70% passing rate; Passing points: 59.5)
Content: ______(Max. 80) Citation:_________(Max. 5)

https://www.schoolcounselor.org/asca/media/asca/ASCA%20National%20Model%20Templates/
Fourth-Edition/ANMExecutiveSummary-4.pdf
Fourth-Edition/FourthEditionChanges.pdf
SMART-Goal.pdf

School Counseling Program Comprehensive Exam
Rubric for Vignette Responses
FALL 2021??????
K-12 Comprehensive Examination Grading Sheet

K-12 Comprehensive Examination Grading Sheet
Question No. Contents 10 pts max. @ Total Scores
1. Describe the 4 themes of the ASCA National Model and how they all apply to this scenario. 10=insightful and thorough; 8-9=complete and specific; 6-7=addressed the question but vague in answers; 1-5=missed significant issues.  
2. Based on the data, what SMART goals (annual student outcome goals) would you establish? 10=insightful and thorough; 8-9=complete and specific; 6-7=addressed the question but vague in answers; 1-5=missed significant issues.  
3. List and describe the timelines and systemic interventions you would implement to achieve the SMART goals listed in #2. 10=covered four strategies and their timeline thoroughly; 8-9=covered three to four strategies and their timeline in specific ways; 6-7=covered two strategies and their timeline in specific ways; 1-5= covered less than two strategies and their timeline  
4. Please describe who you can collaborate and consult with to achieve the goals. Provide a brief description about the consultation process including who the consultant, consultee, and client are and their roles? 10=insightful and thorough; 8-9=complete and specific; 6-7=addressed the question but vague in answers; 1-5=missed significant issues.  
5. What data would you collect to measure the success of your interventions listed in #3 and why? 10=explained appropriate data for four strategies thoroughly; 8-9=explained appropriate data for three to four strategies in specific ways; 6-7=explained appropriate data for two strategies in specific ways; 1-5=explained appropriate data for less than two strategies  
6. Describe three multicultural issues in this vignette that you will take into consideration while implementing individual and systemic level interventions 10=insightful and thorough; 8-9=complete and specific; 6-7=addressed the question but vague in answers; 1-5=missed significant issues.  
7. Describe the ethical issues that you must be mindful of while providing counseling services to the client described in the vignette. 10=insightful and thorough; 8-9=complete and specific; 6-7=addressed the question but vague in answers; 1-5=missed significant issues.  
8. After collecting and analyzing data for success of your interventions, what would your final steps entail? 10=insightful and thorough; 8-9=complete and specific; 6-7=addressed the question but vague in answers; 1-5=missed significant issues.  

Citation: A maximum of 5 points will be given to students. Each citation will receive one point.

TOTAL SCORES: ___________(Max. 85 points, 70% passing rate; Passing points: 59.5)
Content: ______(Max. 80) Citation:_________(Max. 5)

https://www.schoolcounselor.org/getmedia/bd376246-0b4f-413f-b3e0-1b9938f36e68/ANM-executive-summary-4th-ed.pdf
https://www.schoolcounselor.org/About-School-Counseling/ASCA-National-Model-for-School-Counseling-Programs/Templates-Resources

ALTERNATIVE RUBRIC:

ALTERNATIVE RUBRIC
Question No. Exceeds Expectations (8-10) Meets Expectations (5-7) Does not meet expectations (1-4)
1. Describe the 4 themes of the ASCA National Model and how they all apply to this scenario. Thoroughly and clearly describes the themes of ASCA National Model; all elements included and complete Somewhat describes the themes of ASCA National Model; few (1-2) elements missing or incomplete Missing multiple elements to describe the themes of ASCA National Model
2. Based on the data, what SMART goals (annual student outcome goals) would you establish? Thoroughly and clearly describes what SMART goals should be established based on the school data Somewhat describes what SMART goals should be established based on the school data Missing multiple points of the SMART goals that should be established based on the school data
3. List and describe the timelines and systemic interventions you would implement to achieve the SMART goals listed in #2. Thoroughly and clearly describes the timelines and systemic interventions; four strategies and their timeline included and complete Somewhat describes the timelines and systemic interventions; three to two strategies included and complete Describing less than two strategies and their timeline
4. Please describe who you can collaborate and consult with to achieve the goals. Provide a brief description about the consultation process including who the consultant, consultee, and client are and their roles? Thoroughly and clearly describes a comprehensive collaboration and consultation process; all elements included and complete Somewhat articulates describes a comprehensive collaboration and consultation process; few (1-2) elements missing or incomplete Missing multiple elements to describes a comprehensive collaboration and consultation process
5. What data would you collect to measure the success of your interventions listed in #3? Thoroughly and clearly explains appropriate data to collect; appropriate data for four strategies included and complete Somewhat explains appropriate data to collect; appropriate data for three to two strategies included and complete Explains appropriate data for less than two strategies included and complete
6. Describe three multicultural issues in this vignette that you will take into consideration while implementing individual and systemic level interventions. Clearly acknowledges, appropriately implements multicultural issues in this vignette Somewhat acknowledges yet does not appropriately implements multicultural issues in this vignette Does not acknowledge or does not implements multicultural issues in this vignette
7. Describe the ethical issues that you must be mindful of while providing counseling services to the student groups described in the vignette. Thoroughly and clearly describes ethically appropriate approaches and possible ethical issues while providing counseling services to the student groups described in the vignette. Somewhat describes a ethically appropriate approaches and possible ethical issues Does not clearly describe ethically appropriate approaches and possible ethical issues.
8. After collecting and analyzing data for success of your interventions, what would your final steps entail? Thoroughly and clearly describes a comprehensive final steps entail in program assessment Somewhat describes a comprehensive final steps entail in program assessment Missing multiple elements to describe a comprehensive final steps entail in program assessment

Download the PDF

This HTML version was generated with AI assistance and may contain errors or omissions. The original approved PDF remains the official document of record. An alternative accessible format is available upon request from the document creator in accordance with Title II of the ADA.