Mapping the Student Experience

11/16/18 Multiple Subject Program Meeting

Improvement-Implementation Science

  • User-centered
  • Measurable
  • Inquiry driven improvement
  • Networked Improvement
  • Communities

Journey Maps: What & Why

  • A journey map is a visualization of a person’s particular experience.
  • Journey maps help provide insight in understanding successes and challenges in a program, which lead to opportunities for improvement.
  • Practice: Candidate & Faculty Reflection
  • Research: Understand student experience across preparation model types

Completed journey map example with handwritten milestone notes and reflections along a timeline

Slide titled Data Overview with a table listing model, district, and sample size totalsInitial Guiding Questions

  1. Which experiences did students perceive as milestones of the multiple subject program?
  2. How did the students feel about the experiences that they perceived as milestones of the multiple subject program?

What stands out to you?

Data Overview

Data Overview
When Model District N
Spring 2018 Cohort Fowler 9
Spring 2018 Cohort Clovis 21
Spring 2018 Residency Sanger 18
Spring 2018 Residency Fresno 26
Spring 2018 Evening   88
Total     162

Codes

Codes
Program Credential Requirements Placements Life Events
Application (n78) CSET (n47) Mentor Teachers (n68) Trauma (n66)
Coursework (n81) RICA Preparation (n12) Student Teaching (n45) Employment (n31)
Coaches (n34) SVP (n34) Interactions with Children (n29)  
FS Faculty (n46) FAST    
Peers (n43) CBEST    
Communication (n28)      

Which experiences did students perceive as milestones?

Slide titled Student Life Events & Trauma with five quoted student statements about stress and hardship

*Program Event:

  • FAST
  • Credential Exam
  • Coursework
  • Placement
  • Student Teaching

**Mix:

  • Phases
  • Learning Event
  • Life Event

How did the students feel about the experiences that they perceived as milestones of the multiple subject program?

Positive

Most Positive:

  • SVP (n34; 97%)
  • Student Teaching (n45; 93%)

Also Positive:

  • Application process (n78; 78%)
  • Placements (n56; 75%)
  • Mentor teachers (n68; 74%)

Negative

Most Negative:

  • Coursework (n81; 59%)
  • Program communication (n28; 96%)

Also Negative:

  • Traumatic events (n66; 66%)

A 1, 2, 4 Whole Data Dive...

  1. Independent work: Take a few minutes to scan the data.
  2. Pair work: What did you notice?
  3. Team work: What else would you like to know?

Whole group work: What are the implications of the emerging themes from this analysis for our program and practice?

Student Life Events & Trauma

“It was very stressful for me to have found out we needed to take and pass the CSETs in a short amount of time in order to get into the credential program. I had mental breakdowns.” (Evening, Phase 2)

“Foreclosure. Child failing in school.” (Residency, Phase 1)

“My class was so poorly behaved that there were many days that I went home and cried because I felt like a failure.” (Evening, Phase 2)

“Being broke all the time because you don't have time to work and only having $10 for weeks at a time. Being denied food stamps.” (Evening, Phase 2)

“President Trump terminated DACA. My work permit is about to expire and the notice was given in August. “Mr Trump, you cut my wings and filled my heart with fear. Fear, because in an instant everything I have worked so hard for could be taken away.” (iPoP/Disc).”

Next Steps

  • Data analysis across phases and model types.
  • Data available for review and discussion.
  • Invitation: Collaboration on current and/or future research.

Download the PDF

This HTML version was generated with AI assistance and may contain errors or omissions. The original approved PDF remains the official document of record. An alternative accessible format is available upon request from the document creator in accordance with Title II of the ADA.