Reading/Language Arts Program Comprehensive Examination Rubric

(Rev.: 2018)

Reading/Language Arts Program Comprehensive Examination Rubric
Category 4 Exemplary 3 Accomplished 2 Adequate 1 Developing Score
Accuracy of Information
  • all information reported accurately
  • information directly relates to topic
  • most information reported correctly
  • information included applies to topic
  • some information reported correctly
  • may include information that does not apply to topic
  • information reported inaccurately and/or obvious gap in information reported
 
Breadth of Knowledge
  • uses at least 4-5 relevant sources
  • sources are used to make a coherent, informed argument about the topic
  • places the sources in meaningful conversation with each other
  • uses at least 3 relevant sources
  • sources are used to make an informed argument about the topic
  • places the sources in conversation with each other
  • uses at least 2 relevant sources
  • may include sources not relevant to topic
  • begins to make an informed argument about the topic
  • uses at least 1 relevant source
  • includes sources not relevant to topic
  • little, if any, discernable argument made about the topic
 
Application of Knowledge
  • clearly links theory, research, and examples to frame issues of practice
  • includes multiple, meaningful examples to illustrate application of research to practice
  • examples are innovative in their approach
  • draws on a combination of theory, research, and examples to frame issues of practice
  • includes multiple examples to illustrate application of research to practice
  • draws on research or examples to frame issues of practice
  • includes at least one example to illustrate application of research to practice
  • attempts to draw on research or examples to frame issues of practice; research or example may not be relevant
  • includes no relevant applications of research to practice
 
Organization
  • response is a cohesive flow of ideas with transitions and a solid opening and closing
  • apt, seemingly inevitable sequence of paragraphs
  • appropriate, clear and adequate transitions between sentences and paragraphs
  • cohesive flowing narrative in terms of related ideas, meaningful transitions and an argument from beginning to end.
  • distinct units of thought in paragraphs, coherently arranged; some transitions between sentences and paragraphs.
  • written response alludes to related ideas and argument from beginning to end
  • uneven paragraphs sometimes effective, but some brief, weakly unified, or undeveloped
  • some awkward or missing transitions.
  • incoherent in terms of connecting ideas, making meaningful transitions and crafting a solid argument from beginning to end
  • repetitive, wanders, arbitrary or no paragraphs structure, illogical or no transitions
 
Conventions
  • apt and precise diction
  • syntactic variety
  • clear command of Standard English
  • some mechanical difficulties
  • occasional problematic word choice or awkward syntax errors
  • occasional grammar errors
  • some wordiness
  • occasional major grammar errors (e.g. agreement, tense)
  • frequent minor grammar errors (e.g. prepositions, articles)
  • occasional imprecise dictions
  • awkward syntax
  • wordiness
  • frequent major and minor grammar problems
  • frequent imprecise diction
  • wordiness
  • awkward syntax
  • repetitive sentence patterns
  • problems impede meaning
 
Overall Score  
Comments for exams that score below 1.0-1.99  

Download the PDF

This HTML version was generated with AI assistance and may contain errors or omissions. The original approved PDF remains the official document of record. An alternative accessible format is available upon request from the document creator in accordance with Title II of the ADA.