Working with Difference

Dept. of Social Work Education Field Instructor Training
Fresno State
January 10, 2018

DIVERSITY

Challenges in Teaching and Practice
Teaching
Creating a safe enough environment to explore social justice issues and practice implications
Implications for self awareness - lived experience, social identity, owning biases
Learning about “the other”; attending to social power issues
Contextual approach that examines historical, institutional, and societal factors
Practice values
Interpersonal skills, engagement skills, process orientation
Culturally proficient skills, (NASW, 2015), Micro/Macro, Ethics
Curiosity

Field Supervision Goals/Tasks; Challenges

Elements of effective supervision (Munson,1983)
Focus on student’s learning needs
Field Instructor Forthrightness
Mutuality
Communication
Use of case material
Working relationship between student and supervisor
Challenges of future social work practice (Reisch & Jarman-Rohde, 2000)
▪ Marked increase in social and economic inequality
▪ Increased employment insecurity + decline in wages and benefits
▪ Decline in social character of work, e.g., technology, alienation (increased Substance use, IPV, Mental Illness ), reduced intergroup contact

Intergroup Dialogue (IGD) Principles*

Provides systematic approach that integrates didactic and experiential; allows class dynamics (culture) to develop and deepen
Major issue regards students learning about social power and it’s effects on their life (i.e., social identity, interpersonal interactions, lived experience), and role of societal/institutional factors
Based on intergroup contact theory
Gaining traction in teaching social justice in social work
Seeks to raise awareness about privilege, oppression, and structural discrimination
Originally developed to focus on creating dialogue between groups that, historically, have had conflict
Dialogue conducted in a sustained, facilitated context
*Resources are from University of Michigan, Center for Intergroup Dialogue

Key Intergroup Dialogue Concepts

Social Power,
Institutional discrimination
Privilege (Agent Group); knowingly or unknowingly benefit/exploit unfair advantage
Oppression (Target Status); marginalization/invisibility/devaluation; expendable/replaceable.
“Othering”; the “other”
Intersectionality
Ism’s – Racism, Ableism, Heterosexism/Genderism, Classism, Sexism, Religious intolerance, Sizeism…….and more
Equity, Social Justice
Collusion
Ally Building

4 Stages of IGD

1. Creating a Shared Meaning of Dialogue
a. Develop agreed upon norms/guidelines
b. Form and build relationships within the group
2. Identity, Social Relations, and Conflict
a. Understand concept of social group identity, privilege/oppression, intersectionality
b. Learn and practice dialogue skills
c. Explore various types of oppression, differences & commonalities
3. Practicing Dialogue; Hot Topics
a. Examine effects of social structures/institutions on individuals & social groups
b. Probe for and encourage reflection, meaning and sharing
4. Alliances and Other Next Steps
1. Explore what it means to be an ally and take initiative to engage an ally
2. Reflections on future personal/professional growth

Guidelines for Dialogue

Confidentiality
Our primary commitment is to learn from each other
We will not demean, devalue or “put down” people for their experiences, lack of experiences or difference in interpretation of those experiences
We will trust that people are always doing the best they can
Challenge the idea and not the person
Speak your discomfort
Monitor your airtime
Maintain a safe atmosphere

Activity 1: Discussion, Debate and Dialogue

Break into small groups
Review the Handouts and Share:
What distinctions stand out for you in relation to the three types of communication?
Your thoughts about which communication is most “familiar” to you, i.e., that you observe?
Pick a Hot Topic
First talk about the selected Hot Topic (list to be displayed on next slide). Each participant then chooses either Discussion or Debate for an open group exchange for about 5 minutes;
Then shift to Dialogue on the same Hot Topic for about 5 minutes
Debrief for 5 minutes – What did you observe about using the two modes?

Possible Discussion/Debate Hot Topics

Affirmative Action
Same-Sex Marriage
Universal Health Care
Native American Mascot Use in Universities/Athletics
Separation of Church and State in the Educational System
Rape Culture
Assisted Suicide
Other

Social Identity

Reflects groups that we identify with and how others see us
Can vary depending on context
Can be clear or ambiguous (e.g., “multiracial”)
Can be individually chosen and can be ascribed by others
May not be made public or easily ascribed
Can change over time

Activity 2: Social Identity

Review and complete the Social Identity Profile Handout
Pair off with someone and share your profile (5 - 7 minutes each)
Share impressions regarding the activity
DEBRIEF
Peruse the Social Identity Timeline Handout. Reflections on our social identity over time identifies various life course factors and dynamics.

Intersectionality

The complexity of an individual’s social identity highlights the presence of many diverse and meaningful identifications and personal qualities.
Every individual has privilege and oppression
Important to see a person in their complexity and not view them as just one aspect of who they are.
Suggests that the unique combination of identifications means more or less privilege/target status and the importance of recognizing an individual’s totality

The LARA Method – Key dialogue skill

Listen without resistance
Identify & suspend assumptions
Set aside roles & status
Thoughtfully consider what others share
Explore your reactions through your social identity lens
Nurture awareness of others & yourself

LARA

1. Listen – until:
a. You hear the values that they’re speaking from or a feeling/experience that you share.
b. You can be open to them and connect
2. Affirm:
1. Express the connection (e.g., feeling, experience, principle) in their question or statement that represents a fear or issue.
2. If you can’t find anything….find a way to convey that you aren’t going to attack or judge them and you see them as having as much integrity as you do.
4. Respond: Respond to the issue the person raised. If you don’t know the answer, say so; perhaps refer them to other sources.
5. Add information: Add information you want to give the person. Your information might help them see the issue in a new light or redirect the discussion in a more meaningful direction. Identify relevant facts and corrections. Feeling heard, they can be more open to your remarks. Offer resources or personal experience.

Addressing Triggers and Hot Topics

Triggers
When talking with others you find yourself angry or irritated when you hear certain comments or attitudes
Most of us have certain words that trigger strong emotion; we can have an involuntary reaction.
We may have certain topics that are difficult to discuss without trying to “convert” the other person to our way of thinking.

Responding to Triggers and Hot Topics - Triggers cause emotional responses

Leave
Avoidance
Silence
Rationalization
Confusion
Discuss
Confront

Activity 3: Identifying Triggers and Hot Topics

1. Consider situations as a supervisor where you felt triggered by someone’s behavior or discovered that someone you’re interacting with felt triggered.
2. Share responses. [List group’s responses]
3. Small group discussion: In your group, you are invited either as a group or individually, to select one of the listed topics/triggers for small group discussion. Reflect on the supervision situation, trigger experience and what happened.
4. After sharing, apply the IGD principles that could facilitate working effectively with difference in supervision situations similar to what you’ve discussed.

Large Group Discussion and Debriefing

Highlights from small group discussion on triggers/hot topics
Anticipated challenges
How can you use this in supervision and with your staff?

References

Munson, C. (1983). An introduction to clinical social work supervision. New York, N.Y.: The Haworth Press.
NASW (2015). NASW standards and indicators for cultural competence. Washington, D.C.: Author.
Reisch, M. & Jarman-Rohde, L. (2000). The future of social work in the United States: Implications for field education. Journal of Social Work Education, 36(2), 201-214.

Download the PDF

This HTML version was generated with AI assistance and may contain errors or omissions. The original approved PDF remains the official document of record. An alternative accessible format is available upon request from the document creator in accordance with Title II of the ADA.