SWRK 203 Social Welfare Policy II

SOCIAL WORK 203
SOCIAL WELFARE POLICY II
SPRING 2020 Department of Social Work Education
California State University, Fresno
Social Welfare Policy II Instructor Name:
Units: 3.0 Office Location:
Mon/Wed 11:00 AM - 12:15 PM Email: sguthier@mail.fresnostate.edu
Location: Telephone:
Website: Office Hours:

CATALOG STATEMENT

Analysis of social welfare policies, including social, economic, cultural, political, legislative,
administrative and legal dimensions. Comparison of policy analysis frameworks. The role of
social workers in the policy-making process.

COURSE DESCRIPTION

This course builds on the foundation knowledge base of social welfare policies, programs, and
processes covered in Social Welfare Policy I. The locus of attention shifts to emphasize an
examination of political and legislative structures and processes at the Federal, state, and local
level that influence social policy formulation. Both analytical and advocacy skills are developed
to help students gain a working knowledge of the policy issues that are relevant to their field of
practice and their role as policy practitioners.

This course is designed to help the social workers understand their role in policy development
and implementation within their practice settings at the micro, mezzo, and macro levels and to
prepare them to actively engage in policy practice to effect change within those settings. By the
end of the course, students will recognize and understand the historical, social, cultural,
economic, organizational, environmental and global influences that affect social policy. The
students will also be knowledgeable about policy formulation, analyses, implementation and
evaluation.

It is expected that students will spend approximately 2 hours of study time outside of class for
every one hour in class. Since this is a 3 unit class, you should expect to study an average of 6
hours outside of class each week.

PREREQUISITES FOR THE COURSE

SWRK 200. Concurrent enrollment in SWRK 272T is recommended.

REQUIRED COURSE MATERIALS

Jansson, B. (2018). Becoming an effective policy advocate (8th ed). Boston, MA: Cengage
Learning (Plus MindTap Access). Electronic Version Required
(Do not buy the textbook from the bookstore; the text is pre-loaded into your account with
Cengage and MindTap. You will have 10 days from the first day of the semester to
purchase the online version.)

• You are enrolling into an Immediate Access (IA) course - This means that all or some of
the materials are delivered to you digitally through your professor’s Canvas system.
• All IA communication will be delivered to your Fresno State email account…It is YOUR
RESPONSIBILITY to read all communication coming from the Bookstore. Look for
email headers such as “IMPORTANT INFORMATION” or “REMINDERS”
• ALL IA materials are free for the first 10 days of the start of the semester to all students
enrolled - After the 10th day, students who did not OPT OUT of the materials will be
charged on their student account the cost of the materials. This information can be found
in your welcome letter email from the Bookstore. If you didn’t receive an email, please
contact sguthier@mail.fresnostate.edu
• OPTING OUT means that you DO NOT want the materials delivered digitally and that
YOU are responsible to get the materials on your own – usually at a higher cost. If you
OPT OUT, your digital access will be revoked.
• DO NOT purchase digital materials directly from the Publisher website or any other
purchase that would require you to enter a credit card for purchase. You will be billed
TWICE! If you are OPTED IN, the campus will bill your student account.
• THE LAST DAY TO OPT OUT IS January 31st, 2020. – It is YOUR responsibility to
OPT OUT. Once you click on the OPT OUT link in your Welcome Letter email or in
you Professor’s Canvas page, you will receive a confirmation email. If you do not
receive this email, try opting out again or contact the Bookstore.
• DO NOT pay for your materials through Canvas!!! If the link provided requires an
“ACCESS CODE” it will be delivered to you in your Fresno State email account from
the Bookstore. ALL CHARGES will be billed to your student account.
• Student accounts will be charged by February 10th, 2020…You will have until
February 20th, 2020 to pay on your student account either online or at Joyal
Administration. If you’re on financial aid, scholarship or other benefit programs you are
still obligated to pay on your account…Please put this money aside.
• If you enroll after the 10th day of class, you will have 24 hours to review the materials and
OPT OUT of the program.
• Any questions about the IA program can be directed to sguthier@mail.fresnostate.edu

Other Required Materials:
• Laptop Computer or Tablet, is required daily.
• Materials and products for student poster presentations
• Photocopying for fact sheets and policy briefs (assignments)

COURSE GOALS

1. Assess how social welfare and economic policies impact the delivery of and access to social
services [EPAS 5.2]
2. Apply critical thinking to analyze, formulate and advocate for policies that advance human
and social, economic and environmental justice [EPAS 5.3].
3. Assess the value assumptions inherent in current or proposed social welfare policies,
particularly as such value assumptions reflect dominant cultural/political/economic
institutions and negatively affect members of socially, economically, and politically
marginalized groups and other populations-at-risk [EPAS 5].
4. Understand current economic, political, and organizational systems and advocate for policies
consistent with social work values and human rights in a globalized world [EPAS 5].
5. Employ a policy framework to analyze local, state, national, international, and organizational
social welfare policies and social service delivery systems [EPAS 5].
6. Build advocacy skills to effect changes in policy and legislation to promote social justice,
cultural competence, and the empowerment of populations-at-risk [EPAS 5].

LEARNING OBJECTIVES

Students will demonstrate in discussion, class presentations, and written assignments the ability
to:

1.1 Analyze how values and ideology affect the formation of policies. Connect values and
ideology to current policy proposals [EPAS 5].
1.2 Assess the impact of current or proposed policies/programs from a social work value
perspective on disempowered and oppressed populations in the U.S. and internationally,
based on age, race, ethnicity, gender, social class, or physical or mental disability [EPAS
5].
1.3 Articulate an understanding of the social worker’s responsibility, as described in the
NASW Code of Ethics to act as an advocate for distributive justice and human rights
[EPAS 5].
2.1 Understand how social welfare policies can function as forms and mechanism of
oppression and discrimination [EPAS 5].
2.2 Understand how societal trends and politics influence legislative, institutional,
organizational, and international processes and structures, which in turn influence the
development of policies and programs [EPSA 5].

2.3 Describe institutional arrangements that exclude disempowered and oppressed groups
from full political and democratic process and advocate for remedies to address this
exclusion [EPAS 5].
3.1 Identify a current policy problem that affects social workers and/or their constituents
[EPAS 5].
3.2 Select an appropriate policy model or framework that can be used to critically examine
the content and impact of a policy on disadvantaged and oppressed groups. [EPAS 5].
3.3 Use a comprehensive analysis of policy content and impact to advance social, political
and economic well-being of disadvantaged and oppressed groups [EPAS 5].
4.1 Understand the utilization, benefits, and risks associated with the use of a wide range of
advocacy practice skills including: lobbying, giving testimony at a public hearing,
working with the media, working with constituents to develop and implement a lobbying
campaign, and participation in electoral politics [EPAS 5].
4.2 Track a piece of legislation through the state legislative process [EPAS 5].
4.3 Prepare an advocacy action plan that can be used to persuade others to support or oppose
a piece of legislation [EPAS 5].

COURSE REQUIREMENTS/ASSIGNMENTS:

This DISCOVERe course is supported by the MindTap Learning Platform. It is on MindTap the
text is available, weekly homework assignments are completed, and most of the graded
assignments are completed and recorded. Each week beginning the week of 1/27/2020, all
students will have the following MindTap Assignment schedule:

Mondays: “Why am I here?”
Chapter Polling Activity (3 points each) due before 11:59 PM every Monday
throughout the semester.

Wednesdays: “What am I learning?”
Chapter Reading with accompanying videos where pertinent; Chapter Quiz (10
points) due before 11:59 PM every Wednesday throughout the semester.

Saturdays: “How do I practice what I’ve learned?”
Chapter Video Activity (100 points) and Chapter Case Study(s) (3 points) due
before 11:59 PM every Saturday throughout the semester.
“What does this mean to me?”
Chapter Reflection Activity (2 points) due before 11:59 PM every Saturday
throughout the semester.

MAJOR ASSIGNMENTS:

Presentation of a Social Problem

This is a group project. A group of two students will identify a social problem that
is of interest to them, analyze it and present their analyses to the class. The
purpose of this exercise is to accurately describe a social problem that is central to
the social work profession and effectively demonstrate its significance and
urgency to the society. The problem presented can be international, national, state,
regional or local. Presentation of the social problem must be accompanied by an
informational “fact sheet” quantifying the problem. See course schedule and
Canvas/MindTap for dates of student presentation.

Policy Brief: (Common Assignment #1)

The policy brief assignment is a written assignment and group project (2 students)
in which students will develop a policy brief and present it to the class. This
policy brief should build on, and respond to, the social problem presented in the
previous assignment. A policy brief is a document which outlines the rationale for
choosing a particular policy alternative or course of action in a current policy
debate. Policy is political and policy debate is a market-place of competing ideas.
The purpose of this assignment is to apply critical thinking to formulate and
advocate for policies that advance human and social, economic and environmental
justice. Further instructions and grading rubric for this assignment will be posted
on Canvas/MindTap and will be discussed in the class. (Grading Matrix located
in this syllabus preceding the Bibliography.)

Policy Analysis: (Common Assignment #2)

This is a two-part group assignment consisting of: 1) a group poster presentation
on the policy analysis and 2) a group policy analysis paper. Student groups will
apply a policy analysis framework to examine a public policy affecting
populations at-risk or the social work profession. The purpose of this assignment
is to assess how social welfare and economic policies impact the delivery of and
access to social services; and to apply critical thinking to analyze policies that
advance human and social, economic and environmental justice. Further
instructions and grading rubric for this assignment will be posted on
Canvas/MindTap and will be discussed in the class. (Grading Matrix located in
this syllabus preceding the Bibliography.)

Grading policy:

Grading MindTap and class assignments as well as the students’ participation and presence in
class will determine the student’s final grade for the course. Assignments on MindTap are due as
indicated in the course schedule. There is no make-up for MindTap assignments.
If students are having challenges that interfere with a deadline for a class presentation, it is
essential to communicate this to the instructor as soon as possible. The deadlines for class
presentations can be changed proper notice to the instructor is given.
Assignment and Presentation Total Points for grading criteria:

Assignment and Presentation Total Points for grading criteria
Due Date Assignment Points/Percent
Weekly MindTap weekly assignments 1219 points/61%
Assigned Presentation of a Social Problem 131 points/6.5%
Assigned Policy Brief 200 points/10%
Assigned Policy Analysis 250 points/12.5%
Weekly Participation and Attendance 200 points/10%
  TOTAL 2000 points/100%

 

SUBJECT TO CHANGE STATEMENT:

This syllabus and schedule are subject to change in the event of extenuating
circumstances.

TENTATIVE COURSE SCHEDULE

Spring 2020

Tentative Course Schedule Spring 2020
Date Topic Reading/Homework Student Presentations
1 Mon., Jan 20 HOLIDAY – Martin Luther King Jr. Day   1
1 Wed., Jan 22 Introduction Chapter One  
2 Mon., Jan 27 Values & Ideology + Formation of Policies MindTap 2
2 Wed., Jan 29   Chapter Two  
3 Mon., Feb 3 Impact on Oppressed Populations MindTap 3
3 Wed., Feb 5   Chapter Three  
4 Mon., Feb 10 NASW Code of Ethics; Distributive Justice and Human Rights MindTap 4
4 Wed., Feb 12   Chapter Four  
Mon., Feb 17 HOLIDAY – President’s Day MindTap 5
5 Wed., Feb 19 Policies that function as forms of Oppression and Discrimination Chapter Five  
6 Mon., Feb 24 Societal Trends, Politics and Policy Formulation MindTap Social Problem 2 Student Groups
6 Wed., Feb 26   Chapter Six Social Problem 2 Student Groups
7 Mon., March 2 Exclusion through policy MindTap Social Problem 2 Student Groups
7 Wed., March 4   Chapter Seven Social Problem 2 Student Groups
8 Mon., March 9 Identification of a policy problem MindTap Social Problem 2 Student Groups
8 Wed., March 11   Chapter Eight Social Problem 2 Student Groups
9 Mon., March 16 Selecting appropriate policy models or frameworks for examination of groups MindTap Social Problem 2 Student Groups
9 Wed., March 18   Chapter Nine Social Problem 2 Student Groups
10 Mon., March 23 The Comprehensive Analysis of policy content MindTap Social Problem 2 Student Groups
10 Wed., March 25   Chapter Ten Social Problem 2 Student Groups
11 Mon., March 30 The Wide Range of Advocacy Practice Skills MindTap Policy Brief Presentation 2 Student Groups
11 Wed., April 1   MindTap Policy Brief Presentation 2 Student Groups
Mon., April 6 Spring Break   Policy Brief Presentation 2 Student Groups
Wed., April 8 Spring Break Chapter 11 Policy Brief Presentation 2 Student Groups
12 Mon., April 13 The State Legislative Process MindTap Policy Brief Presentation 2 Student Groups
12 Wed., April 15   Chapter 12 Policy Brief Presentation 2 Student Groups
13 Mon., April 20 The use of Persuasion in Advocating for an Action Plan MindTap Policy Brief Presentation 2 Student Groups
14 Wed., April 22   Chapter 13 Policy Brief Presentation 2 Student Groups
15 Mon., April 27   MindTap Policy Brief Presentation 2 Student Groups
15 Wed., April 29     Policy Brief Presentation 2 Student Groups
16 Mon., May 4     Policy Analysis DUE
16 Wed., May 6 Last Day of Instruction    
Finals week Dates
Finals week Days Dates
Final Exam Preparation & Faculty Consultation Days: Thursday and Friday May 7 – 8
Final Exam in this course Monday, May 11 11:00 AM – 1:00 PM May 11, 2020

 

Policy Brief Assignment Grading Matrix

Student(s): ______________________________________________________________

Policy Brief Assignment Grading Matrix
  Excellent 90 – 100% Competent 80-89% Developing 70-79% Poor Proficiency < 69% Score
Policy Brief Presentation The policy brief presentation addresses populations at risk/social work profession. All elements of the policy brief are presented clearly and comprehensively, delivering important and relevant information necessary for full understanding. The policy brief presentation addresses populations at risk/social work profession. All elements of the policy brief are presented, but some minor information is missing, needs further explanation, or lacks substantial depth. The policy brief presentation addresses populations at risk/social work profession, however the presentation leaves out important information, is ambiguous, vague or barely adequate. 1 to 2 elements are missing. The policy brief presentation does not address populations at risk/social work profession. The presentation is poorly organized and difficult to understand. 3 or more elements are missing.  
Persuasive Argument (Advocacy) The persuasive argument is clear and comprehensive using all 3 components of Aristotle’s persuasion robustly. Argument strongly appeals to most of the audience. Reasonable actions to take are requested from the audience. The persuasive argument is clear and described using all 3 components of Aristotle’s persuasion. Argument appeals to most of the audience. Reasonable actions to take are requested from the audience. A nominal persuasive argument is described. Argument does not have strong appeal to most of the audience. Only uses 2 of 3 components of Aristotle’s persuasion. Unreasonable or no actions are requested from the audience. A poor persuasive argument is provided. Argument has no appeal to most of the audience. One or no components of Aristotle’s persuasion are used. Unreasonable or no actions are requested from the audience.  

Policy brief rubric

Policy Brief Document Grading Matrix
  Excellent 90 – 100% Competent 80-89% Developing 70-79% Poor Proficiency < 69% Score
Policy Brief Document The policy brief contains all of the required elements. The format and visual presentation is excellent, no writing errors seen, information is correct and easy to comprehend. The policy brief contains all of the required elements. The format and visual presentation is adequate, very minimal writing errors seen, information is correct and understandable with some studying. The policy brief contains all of the required elements, but format and visual presentation is unappealing, several writing errors seen, some information is missing, incorrect or hard to understand. One of the elements is missing The policy brief is poorly organized, inadequate unappealing and overall very difficult to understand. Two or more of the required elements are missing.  
Individual Student Contribution to Assignment Student was cooperative and contribution was excellent demonstrating above average collaboration skills. Student was cooperative and contribution was satisfactory, student was dependable. Individual was cooperative, however contribution was minimally satisfactory and student was at times undependable. Student was uncooperative, no substantial contribution was made to the assignment or undependable.  
Individual Presentation Superior presence, excellent oral skills and command of the topic. Very appealing to the audience. Good presence, good oral skills and satisfactory command of the topic. Appeals to the audience at times Lacks presence, but, oral presentation was satisfactory. Lacks command of the topic at times and audience appeal Oral presentation was unsatisfactory, did not have a group presentation role, absent. Final Score

Instructions: Enter a percentage score in the far right column for each rubric element. In the
Final Score cell, calculate the final score by adding all element percentage scores and dividing by
5 (elements) for the final score.

Policy Analysis Paper Grading Rubric

Student: ________________________________________________________________

Policy Analysis Paper Grading Rubric
  Excellent 90 – 100% Competent 80-89% Developing 70-79% Poor Proficiency < 69% Score
Social Problem Historical, economic, political. Indicators & markers. Data. Consequences. Variations. A clear and comprehensive description of the social problem is provided that includes: 1) relevant historical, economic political content, 2) indicators & markers, 3) data, 4) consequences, and 5) variations necessary for full understanding. A clear description of the social problem is provided, but some minor information required in areas 1 through 5 is missing or description and analysis lacks substantial depth. A social problem is stated, but a full description is missing, or important information is missing or barely adequate or one of the 5 required areas for the social problem description/analysis is missing. The social problem description is poorly organized, difficult to understand or no clear description is provided. Two or more of the 5 required areas are missing.  
Description: Causal Chain. Values. Winner & Losers A clear and comprehensive description of the social problem is provided that includes: 1) a causal chain, 2) societal values and 3) winner and losers necessary for full understanding. A clear description of the social problem is provided, but some minor information required in areas 1 through 3 is missing or description and analysis lacks substantial depth A social problem is stated, but a full description is missing or important information is missing or barely adequate or 1 of the 3 required areas for the social problem description/analysis is missing. The social problem description is poorly organized, difficult to understand & no clear description provided. Two or more of the 3 required areas are missing.  
Description of the Policy Meant to Address the Social Problem A clear and comprehensive description of the policy is provided including: 1) its salient features, 2) legislative history, 3) where it is codified, and 4) the responsible agency(ies), necessary for full understanding. A clear description of the policy is provided, but some minor information required in areas 1 through 4 is missing, incomplete or lacks substantial depth A description of the policy is provided however, important information is missing, incorrect or barely adequate. One of the 4 required areas for the policy description is missing. The description of the policy is poorly organized and difficult to understand. The policy described does not relate to the social problem  
Policy Analysis Framework A clear and comprehensive discussion of policy analysis framework is provided including: 1) a correct rationale for the selected framework, 2) a clear and comprehensive analysis of each elements of the framework reflecting critical thinking, and 3) a proper conclusion about the fit of the policy to the social problem. A clear and adequate discussion of policy analysis framework is provided, but some minor information required in areas 1 through 3 is missing, incomplete or lacks substantial depth in critical thinking. A discussion of the policy analysis framework is provided however, important information is missing, incorrect or barely adequate. One of the 3 required areas is missing. Very little critical thinking demonstrated. The discussion of policy analysis framework is poorly organized and difficult to understand. The policy described does not relate to the social problem. Two or all of the 3 required areas are missing. No critical thinking demonstrated.  
Writing Analysis reads like a single author. Excellent use of paragraph/sentence structure, punctuation, spelling, word choice, etc. Very minimal writing errors seen. Very minimal (1-2) APA errors seen. Analysis reads like a single author. Good use of paragraph/sentence structure, punctuation, spelling, word choice, etc. Some errors seen sporadically. Some (3-4) APA errors seen Analysis reads like multiple authors. Below average use of paragraph/sentence structure, punctuation, spelling, word choice, etc. Errors are seen consistently (>4). Analysis reads like multiple authors. Use of paragraph/sentence structure, punctuation, spelling, word choice, etc., is so poor, reader cannot comprehend the subject matter. APA not used or used incorrectly throughout.  

Policy analysis rubric pages

Policy Analysis Paper Individual Student Contribution
Excellent 90 – 100% Competent 80-89% Developing 70-79% Poor Proficiency < 69% Score
Student was cooperative and contribution was excellent demonstrating above average collaboration skills. Student was cooperative and contribution was satisfactory, student was dependable. Individual was cooperative, however contribution was minimally satisfactory and student was at times undependable. Student was uncooperative, no substantial contribution was made to the assignment or undependable. Final Score

Instructions: Enter a percentage score in the far right column for each rubric element. In the
Final Score cell, calculate the final score by adding all element percentage scores and dividing by
6 (elements) for the final score.

Bibliograhy

Blau, J., & Abramowitz, M. (2007). The dynamics of social welfare policy (2nd
ed.). New York:
Oxford University Press.
Burch, H. (1996). Basic social policy and planning: Strategies and practice methods. New York:
Haworth.
Davis, K., & Bent-Goodley, T. (2004). The color of social policy. Alexandria, VA: Council on
Social Work Education.
Dobelstein, A. (2003). Social welfare policy and analysis. Pacific Grove, CA:
Thomson/Brooks/Cole.
Dolgoff, R., & Feldstein (2007). Understanding social welfare: A search for social justice (7th
ed.). Boston: Pearson Education.
Dye, T. (1998). Understanding public policy (9th
ed.). Upper Saddle River, NJ: Prentice-Hall.
Ezell, M. (2001). Advocacy in the human services. Belmont, CA: Brooks/Cole.
Gilbert, N., & Terrell, P. (2004). Dimensions of social welfare policy (6th
ed.). Needham Heights,
MA: Allyn & Bacon.
Haynes, K., & Mickelson, J. (2002). Affecting change: Social workers in the political arena (4th
ed.). Boston: Allyn & Bacon.
Hick, S. & McNutt, J. (2002). Advocacy, activism, and the Internet. Chicago, IL: Lyceum Books.
Jackson, R. A., Brown, R. D., & Wright, G. C. (1998). Registration, turnout, and the electoral
representativeness of U.S. state electorates. American Politics Quarterly, 26(3), 259-272.
Karger, H. J., & Stoesz, D. (2005). American social welfare policy: A pluralist approach (4th
ed.). Boston: Allyn & Bacon.
Linhorst, D. (2002). Federalism and social justice: Implication for social work. Social Work, 47,
201-208.
Millar, J., & Austin, M. (2006). The role of social workers in welfare to work programs:
International perspectives on policy and practice. Journal of Policy Practice, 5(2/3),
149-158.
Pearlmutter, S. (2002). Achieving political practice: Integrating individual need and social
action. Journal of Progressive Human Services, 13(1), 31-51.
Perkins, D. (1995). Speaking truth to power: Empowerment ideology as social intervention and
policy. American Journal of Community Psychology, 23, 765-794.
Piven, F.F., & Cloward, R. (2000). Why Americans still don’t vote and why politicians want it
that way. Boston, MA: Beacon Press.
Poindexter, C. (1999). Promises in the plague: Passage of the Ryan White Comprehensive AIDS
Resources Emergency Act as a case study for legislative Action Health & Social Work,
24 (10, p35-41.
Prigoff, A. (2000). Economics for social workers: Social outcomes of economic globalization
with strategies for community action. Belmont, CA: Brooks/Cole.
Reichert, E. (2004). Social work and human rights: A foundation for policy and practice. New
York: Columbia University Press.
Putnam, R. (2000). Bowling alone. New York: Touchtone Book.
Richan, W. (1996). Lobbying for social change. New York: Haworth.
Scanlon, E., Harnett, H., & Harding, S. (2006). An analysis of the political activities of NASW
state chapters. Journal of Policy Practice, 5(4), 41-54.
Sevenhuijsen, S.; Bozalek, V., Gouws, A.; Minnaar-Mcdonald, M. (2003). South African social
welfare policy: An analysis using the ethic of care. Critical Social Policy, 23, 299-321.
Schneider, R., & Lester, L. (2001). Social work advocacy: A new framework for action. Belmont,
Ca: Brooks Cole
Verba, S., Schlozman, K., & Brady, H. (1997, May/June). The big tilt: Participatory inequality in
America. The American Prospect, 32, 74-80.
Welss, I., Gal, J., Cnaan, R., Majiaglic, R., (2002). What kind of social policy do social work
students prefer? A comparison of students in three countries. International Social Work,
45 (1), 59-81.

 

Download the PDF

This HTML version was generated with AI assistance and may contain errors or omissions. The original approved PDF remains the official document of record. An alternative accessible format is available upon request from the document creator in accordance with Title II of the ADA.